Palm Springs, CA
The Palm Springs City Council voted Wednesday to approve a long-debated policy allowing the removal of dead palm fronds, known locally as “skirts,” from many of the city’s roughly 2,150 California fan palms, ending years of back-and-forth over how to balance public safety with the trees’ iconic look.
Under the new policy, city crews will prioritize frond removal on trees in high-traffic commercial corridors, including the rows of California fan palms lining downtown. Council members carved out exceptions for designated historic sites, community gateway areas, city-landscaped areas and parks valued for their heritage character, directing staff to weigh those factors on a tree-by-tree basis rather than applying a blanket rule.
The debate traces back to a 2007 General Plan update that set a goal of gradually replacing the city’s nonnative Mexican fan palms with California fan palms as older trees die off. A 2009 policy required removal of fronds from Mexican fan palms while leaving California fan palm skirts largely untouched, aside from trimming needed to maintain 12 feet of clearance above the ground.
That approach came under renewed scrutiny after a mother and her infant son were injured in March 2024 when a falling frond struck them outside the Welwood Murray Memorial Library in downtown Palm Springs. The council considered changing the policy that summer but delayed action after hearing public pushback, instead directing staff to study alternative safety measures.
According to a city staff report, individual fronds can weigh more than 20 pounds, and up to 50 are added to each tree every year meaning an untrimmed skirt can eventually weigh between 1,000 and more than 4,000 pounds. City Attorney Jeff Ballinger told the council Palm Springs has fielded at least 11 claims tied to falling fronds since 2019, including one that resulted in a $100,000 settlement.
Councilmember Jeffrey Bernstein framed the vote as a safety matter rather than an aesthetic one, saying the city has already seen accidents and doesn’t want to be responsible for a more serious one down the road.
About 20 residents spoke against the proposal, raising concerns about wildlife habitat loss and the potential erosion of the city’s historic character. Bettina Rosmarino, land acquisition director for the Oswit Land Trust, argued the fronds support a layered ecosystem of insects, reptiles, small mammals and birds, and warned that cutting skirts could actually make trees less stable rather than more so. Jane Garrison, the land trust’s founder and executive director, urged the city to limit trimming to the downtown pedestrian core and form a committee to evaluate individual trees there.
The council’s compromise directs staff to focus removal efforts on high-traffic commercial zones while sparing trees in historic and ecologically significant locations. Officials also plan to use signage and other measures such as relocating benches away from trees with heavy skirts to reduce risk in areas where fronds remain.
The rollout is expected to unfold over four years, beginning with an initial $300,000 investment approved as part of Wednesday’s vote. Total costs for the project are projected to exceed $1 million. Public Works Director David McAbee said every tree will be inspected individually, both from the ground and from above, before any trimming takes place.
You must be logged in to post a comment.